Free tool

CS Business Case Builder

CSMs say they're overloaded. The CFO wants proof first. This builder starts from the load on the team and the retention gap your own data shows between lighter and heavier books. It claims only part of that gap, then shows how small a recovery pays for the hires.

Example figures

The request
The segment today

That's $12.0M of ARR, at 80 accounts per CSM.

The hires

Fully loaded: salary, bonus, benefits and payroll taxes.

Other costs

Recruiting fees, or a tool the new CSMs need.

NRR from your own data

Compare books near your target load with books near today's load, in the same segment. You can also compare the same team at two points in time.

What you'll claim

A CFO will trust part of the gap more than all of it. NRR climbs in a straight line to the level you claim.

CSM turnover (optional)

Recruiting fees plus the months a new CSM takes to ramp. Leave all three blank to keep turnover out of the case.

The math

Ask your finance team for the discount rate they use.

The memo
Accounts per CSM 80 → 48 Today and with the hires, against 30 to 75 for mid-touch
Break-even over five years 1.6 points 27% of the 6-point gap your data shows
Pays for itself Month 36 Claiming half of the 6-point gap: 3 points
Five-year net, today's dollars $832K $1.3M before discounting at 10%

The hires take the load from 80 to 48 accounts per CSM, inside the 30 to 75 range for mid-touch.

Your data shows a 6-point gap in NRR between lighter and heavier books. With 60 accounts behind the smaller sample, one lost account moves its NRR about 1.7 points.

Recovering 1.6 points, 27% of the gap, pays for the hires over five years. This case claims 3 points and pays back in month 36.

The lift it takes
Pays back byNRR lift neededShare of your gapYour 3 points
Month 245.2 points87%No
Month 363 points50%Yes
Month 482.1 points35%Yes
Month 601.6 points27%Yes
Running totals by month Gross profit kept and turnover savedCost

Memo

To
CFO
From
VP of Customer Success
Re
Two CSMs for the mid-market segment

The ask

Two CSMs at $150K each, fully loaded: $300K a year.

The problem

The Mid-market segment has 240 accounts with $12.0M of ARR. Its three CSMs carry 80 each, above the 30 to 75 range for mid-touch. The hires bring that to 48, inside it.

The evidence

In our own renewal data, lighter books ran at 104% NRR across 60 accounts, against 98% across 90 accounts on heavier books. That's a 6-point gap. One lost account moves the smaller sample about 1.7 points.

The return

This case claims half of that gap, 3 points, reached by year 2. It pays for itself in month 36. Over five years it keeps $2,718K of gross profit and saves $81K in turnover, against $1,500K of cost. That's a net return of $1,299K, or $832K in today's dollars at a 10% discount rate.

What it takes

To break even within five years, the segment's NRR has to rise 1.6 points, 27% of the gap. To pay back within three years, it has to rise 3 points.

How we'll check it

At six months, we'll report accounts per CSM and the share of accounts with no CSM contact in 90 days. At twelve months, we'll compare renewals on the relieved books with the 98% NRR they ran at before.

Assumptions

  • 240 accounts at $50K each, all in the Mid-market segment. New logos aren't part of this case.
  • Without the hires, the segment keeps renewing at 98% NRR, the rate on heavier books.
  • With them, NRR climbs in a straight line to 101% over 2 years, then holds.
  • Contracts renew evenly through the year, so added revenue builds month by month.
  • Gross margin of 75% on the added revenue.
  • Turnover goes from 35% a year on three CSMs, about 1.1 departures, to 15% on five CSMs, about 0.8. Each one costs $60K to replace.
  • Costs are fully loaded and stay flat.
  • Payback isn't discounted. Today's dollars use a 10% discount rate.
YearARR gap at year endGross profit keptTurnover savedCostRunning total
Year 1$180K$68K$9K$300K-$223K
Year 2$535K$268K$18K$300K-$237K
Year 3$886K$533K$18K$300K$14K
Year 4$1,233K$795K$18K$300K$527K
Year 5$1,578K$1,054K$18K$300K$1,299K
Send to Ariel

How this is calculated

The load
Accounts in the segment divided by CSMs, today and with the hires, checked against the accounts per CSM your coverage model usually carries.
The gap
NRR on your lighter books minus NRR on your heavier ones. Each lost account moves a book's NRR by about 100 divided by the number of accounts behind it, so a small sample makes a noisy gap.
Two paths
Both start from the segment's ARR. One keeps renewing at the heavier books' NRR, and the other climbs in a straight line by the share of the gap you claim, reached in the year you pick. Every account in the segment counts, since every CSM in it gets more time once the load drops.
Gross profit kept
The ARR gap between the two paths times your gross margin. Contracts renew evenly through the year, so each year counts the average of the gap at its start and its end.
Turnover saved
Departures a year at today's turnover on today's team, minus departures at a healthy load on the bigger team, times the cost to replace a CSM. It phases in with the retention gain.
Payback
The first month when the running benefit covers the running cost. The one-time cost lands in month 1, and payback isn't discounted.
Today's dollars
Each month's benefit minus its cost, discounted at your rate.
Lift needed
The smallest rise in the segment's NRR that pays back by each month, rounded up to a tenth of a point so the lift shown always gets there.

Every figure on this page is worked out from the figures shown next to it, so a CFO checking it with a calculator gets the same answer.

Coverage ranges come from the RetentionForge CS Org Design Checklist.

Send it to me

Want me to pressure-test the case before your CFO does?

Next step

Building the headcount case is one of the things we work on in coaching.

Between sessions, I review budget requests and board decks before they reach your CEO or CFO.