Memo
- To
- CFO
- From
- VP of Customer Success
- Re
- Two CSMs for the mid-market segment
The ask
Two CSMs at $150K each, fully loaded: $300K a year.
The problem
The Mid-market segment has 240 accounts with $12.0M of ARR. Its three CSMs carry 80 each, above the 30 to 75 range for mid-touch. The hires bring that to 48, inside it.
The evidence
In our own renewal data, lighter books ran at 104% NRR across 60 accounts, against 98% across 90 accounts on heavier books. That's a 6-point gap. One lost account moves the smaller sample about 1.7 points.
The return
This case claims half of that gap, 3 points, reached by year 2. It pays for itself in month 36. Over five years it keeps $2,718K of gross profit and saves $81K in turnover, against $1,500K of cost. That's a net return of $1,299K, or $832K in today's dollars at a 10% discount rate.
What it takes
To break even within five years, the segment's NRR has to rise 1.6 points, 27% of the gap. To pay back within three years, it has to rise 3 points.
How we'll check it
At six months, we'll report accounts per CSM and the share of accounts with no CSM contact in 90 days. At twelve months, we'll compare renewals on the relieved books with the 98% NRR they ran at before.
Assumptions
- 240 accounts at $50K each, all in the Mid-market segment. New logos aren't part of this case.
- Without the hires, the segment keeps renewing at 98% NRR, the rate on heavier books.
- With them, NRR climbs in a straight line to 101% over 2 years, then holds.
- Contracts renew evenly through the year, so added revenue builds month by month.
- Gross margin of 75% on the added revenue.
- Turnover goes from 35% a year on three CSMs, about 1.1 departures, to 15% on five CSMs, about 0.8. Each one costs $60K to replace.
- Costs are fully loaded and stay flat.
- Payback isn't discounted. Today's dollars use a 10% discount rate.
| Year | ARR gap at year end | Gross profit kept | Turnover saved | Cost | Running total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $180K | $68K | $9K | $300K | -$223K |
| Year 2 | $535K | $268K | $18K | $300K | -$237K |
| Year 3 | $886K | $533K | $18K | $300K | $14K |
| Year 4 | $1,233K | $795K | $18K | $300K | $527K |
| Year 5 | $1,578K | $1,054K | $18K | $300K | $1,299K |
Made with the free CS Business Case Builder at retentionforge.io.